Books Like Once Upon a Broken Heart: 9 Enchanting Reads to Devour Next

Stephanie Garber’s Once Upon a Broken Heart captivated readers with its enchanting blend of romance, mystery and fantasy. At its heart, the story explores the power of love, the consequences of bargains struck with magical beings, and the pursuit of one's heart's desire. The protagonist, Evangeline Fox, finds herself entangled in a world where the lines between reality and fairy tales blur, bringing to life the whimsy and wonder that fans of magical realism adore.

Readers are drawn to Garber's lush storytelling, which evokes a sense of wonder and possibility. The novel's mixture of intricate plot twists, star-crossed romance and a richly imagined world makes it a captivating read. If you’re itching for more adventures that echo the same magical allure, we've compiled a list of books that promise to satisfy your craving for the fantastical and the romantic.

What to read after Once Upon a Broken Heart

Caraval by Stephanie Garber

Before diving into Once Upon a Broken Heart, many readers were enchanted by Garber’s debut, Caraval. This novel introduces a magical carnival that blurs reality with illusion, much like the magical elements in Evangeline's story. The intense sisterly bond and the cunning games played in the backdrop of a lush, mysterious setting will feel familiar yet thrillingly new.

The Night Circus by Erin Morgenstern

Fans of magical settings will adore The Night Circus, where a mysterious circus that only opens at night becomes the backdrop for a magical duel between two young illusionists. The dreamlike quality and the intricate dance of romance and rivalry provide a similar enchanting escape.